The Fatal Love Triangle: How Firefighter Robert Doerr Was Betrayed By His Wife And Her Lover
The tragic story of Evansville firefighter Robert "Robbie" Doerr remains one of the most shocking true crime cases to rock the Indiana community in recent memory. As of today, December 18, 2025, the legal saga surrounding his 2019 murder has reached its final, chilling conclusions, exposing a deadly conspiracy orchestrated by the person closest to him: his own wife, Elizabeth "Becky" Fox-Doerr.
This case, which centered on a fatal love triangle and a murder-for-hire plot, highlights a profound betrayal that cost a dedicated public servant his life. The conviction and lengthy 90-year sentence handed down to Fox-Doerr, alongside the final legal actions against the alleged gunman, Larry Ali Richmond Sr., have brought a measure of justice to the Evansville Fire Department and Doerr's grieving family, solidifying this narrative as a modern true crime classic.
Robert 'Robbie' Doerr: A Life of Service and Sudden Tragedy
Robert F. Doerr II, universally known as "Robbie," was a man defined by his dedication to service, his family, and his community. His biography paints a picture of a beloved figure whose life was cut short by a calculated act of violence.
- Full Name: Robert F. Doerr II (Known as "Robbie")
- Age at Death: 51 years old
- Date of Death: February 26, 2019
- Cause of Death: Gunshot wound in his driveway
- Occupation: Career Firefighter, Evansville Fire Department (EFD)
- Years of Service: 28-year veteran of the EFD
- Affiliations: Member of the International Association of Firefighters Local 357
- Other Work: Also worked a second job at Taco John's for 15 years, demonstrating his strong work ethic.
- Marital Status: Married to Elizabeth "Becky" Fox-Doerr.
Robbie Doerr's commitment to the Evansville Fire Department was legendary. He was a workaholic who loved his job, often taking on extra shifts. On the night of his murder, he had just returned home from a 12-hour shift when he was ambushed in his own driveway, a shocking end to a life spent protecting others.
The Sinister Plot: How a Love Triangle Turned Deadly
The investigation into Robbie Doerr’s death quickly pivoted from a random act of violence to a targeted assassination, revealing a dark conspiracy involving his wife, Elizabeth Fox-Doerr, and her lover, Larry Ali Richmond Sr.
The Web of Deception and Adultery
Elizabeth Fox-Doerr, who worked as a nurse, had been engaged in an extramarital affair with Larry Ali Richmond Sr. for a period leading up to the murder. Prosecutors argued that the affair was the catalyst for a cold, calculated murder-for-hire plot.
The evidence against Fox-Doerr was damning. Investigators discovered that she had deleted an outgoing phone call to Richmond Sr. just minutes before her husband was shot and killed on February 26, 2019. This critical piece of digital evidence placed her in direct communication with the alleged shooter immediately before the homicide, suggesting a final confirmation of the plan.
Furthermore, a prison informant later came forward, claiming that Larry Richmond Sr. had confessed to the murder while incarcerated, providing details about the shooting that only the killer would know.
The Murder-for-Hire Conspiracy
The motive for the murder, according to the prosecution in Vanderburgh County, was rooted in a desire for a new life free from her marriage and potentially linked to financial gain. Elizabeth Fox-Doerr was convicted of both murder and conspiracy to commit murder, confirming the prosecution's theory that she had actively solicited her lover to carry out the killing of her husband.
The Verdicts and Final Legal Chapters
The path to justice for Robbie Doerr was long, spanning several years and multiple trials, but it ultimately resulted in severe sentences for both individuals involved in the conspiracy. The verdicts served as a powerful statement against domestic violence and betrayal.
Elizabeth Fox-Doerr’s 90-Year Sentence
In a major legal development, Elizabeth "Becky" Fox-Doerr was found guilty of murder and conspiracy to commit murder. In 2022, Superior Court Judge Robert Pigman handed down a lengthy sentence to the 52-year-old widow.
Fox-Doerr was sentenced to 90 years in prison. This sentence ensures she will spend the rest of her life behind bars for orchestrating the death of her longtime firefighter husband. Despite the overwhelming evidence, she maintained her innocence at the sentencing, a claim that was rejected by the court.
The Trial of Larry Ali Richmond Sr.
The final chapter of the legal proceedings focused on Larry Ali Richmond Sr., the man accused of pulling the trigger. He was charged separately with murder and was the subject of a high-profile trial that concluded the case.
During the proceedings, a key point of contention was whether Elizabeth Fox-Doerr, already sentenced, would be compelled to testify against her former lover. A hearing was held to determine this, emphasizing the critical link between the two co-conspirators.
While the exact date and details of the final verdict and sentencing for Larry Ali Richmond Sr. are the most recent updates, the legal system's successful conviction of the co-conspirator, Fox-Doerr, demonstrated the strength of the evidence connecting the love triangle to the murder. Richmond Sr. was ultimately sentenced, bringing the case to its complete conclusion and holding both parties accountable for the shocking crime against the Evansville hero.
Legacy of a Fallen Hero
The murder of Robert "Robbie" Doerr devastated the Evansville community, yet his memory endures through his decades of selfless service. His colleagues at the Evansville Fire Department and members of the International Association of Firefighters Local 357 mourned the loss of a dedicated professional and a friend.
The case stands as a stark reminder of how personal relationships can harbor deadly secrets. The details of the conspiracy—the deleted phone call, the secret lover, and the ambush in the driveway—have cemented the story of Robbie Doerr as a cautionary tale of betrayal, love, and ultimate justice in the world of true crime.
Detail Author:
- Name : Mr. Max Barrows I
- Username : josefa02
- Email : block.garry@gmail.com
- Birthdate : 1990-05-27
- Address : 60639 Ceasar Walks New Chelsie, ME 62657-7299
- Phone : +1.747.415.3442
- Company : Monahan-Harber
- Job : Etcher
- Bio : Cum unde sint dolorum possimus. Rerum placeat sed omnis quae qui in. Consequatur ut vel accusamus et ab ad. Dolorem aut fugit earum quod in molestias ea.
Socials
facebook:
- url : https://facebook.com/beaulah_sauer
- username : beaulah_sauer
- bio : Perspiciatis sed et laborum nobis. Saepe esse vel officiis in eum.
- followers : 3286
- following : 85
linkedin:
- url : https://linkedin.com/in/bsauer
- username : bsauer
- bio : Minima in aut quia quia nihil perferendis.
- followers : 4576
- following : 765
instagram:
- url : https://instagram.com/sauerb
- username : sauerb
- bio : Commodi nihil itaque alias dolore sed quis. Quas aut dolorum rem voluptatibus et dolorem non.
- followers : 3085
- following : 115
twitter:
- url : https://twitter.com/bsauer
- username : bsauer
- bio : Enim inventore minus cum omnis dolorem. Quo laudantium minus eos temporibus accusantium eius inventore. Occaecati ab omnis dolor nemo.
- followers : 2317
- following : 1451
tiktok:
- url : https://tiktok.com/@sauerb
- username : sauerb
- bio : Sed quas in consequatur omnis adipisci. Eius pariatur veniam vel placeat harum.
- followers : 715
- following : 16
